In order of weight:
Judging (27%)
Awards Dinner (16.2%)
Ruleset (16.2%)
Open Sparring on Sundays (13.5%)
Directors (13.5%)
Ring Size and number of rings (10.8%)
Technology (10.8%)
Finals format (all bronzes matches first, gold matches second) (10.8%)
Interesting how Judging was the #1 thing, but director was down the list at #5. We had a 1+1 format, and the director was the final arbiter on calls. To be fair, a large majority of comments in this section were along the lines of “Great event, but I had to pick things,” so take it with a grain of salt.
Let’s take a look at some of the feedback about these:
The judging/directing wasnt bad but probably the weakest part of the tournament. Calls on quality and elbow shots were inconsistent. Impressed that the judges DID NOT seem biased towards particular fencers.
But calls were inconsistent between rings, and deviated pretty significantly from the provided rules. More experience, training and rest time for judges/directors.
I loved the judging format, but I feel by the end of the tournament the quality starting going down. I definitely am interested in reviewing the video to see if I was crazy on what I felt or thought happened in several instances. I believe more rest and rotation of judges would alleviate this.
Takeaways
‘Quality’ is one of the most inconsistent metrics we use to judge strikes, and while this is a common complaint at tournaments, we’ve got some work to do in order to make that consistent. We’ll be publishing explainer videos this year that will go over the more nuanced parts of the ruleset, such as quality, so that way everyone has a better understanding of the intent and rubric for scoring.
Deviation from the rules was only brought up by this one person, and they didn’t provide any examples, but it still is an issue of consistency that we’ll be fixing.
Rest for directors and judges is a important topic, however. Our goal was to run 2019 with as few outside volunteers as possible. however, with the sheer number of matches, this meant that judges and directors were EXHAUSTED by the end. For 2020, we will be opening up judge and director registration - the goal will still be to keep outside volunteers lower, but to make sure we can have as many fresh eyes as possible during pools and eliminations.
What people liked the MOST about MCHO 2019